Skip to main content
(678) 915-2634 Contact Us
Kagan Issues Bankruptcy Ruling in First Supreme Court Opinion Atlanta, GA

Personal Attention & Experience Since 1971 Family-Owned, Family Focused

Client Reviews

Kagan Issues Bankruptcy Ruling in First Supreme Court Opinion

lawyer in a lawyers library

This week, in her first ruling of her new judicial career, Supreme Court Justice Elena Kagan delivered the opinion on the bankruptcy case of Ransom v. FIA, stating that the case boiled down to a simple, clear interpretation of the United States bankruptcy code. Kagan wrote a detailed opinion, speaking for seven other Supreme Court justices, with a lone dissenter in Justice Antonin Scalia.

The case, which was brought by a man named Jason Ransom, was primarily concerned with the deductions that are allowed by the bankruptcy code while a filer is under bankruptcy protection. Under the code, a filer is allowed to keep portions of their incomes from creditors in order to pay for living expenses. Deductions are allowed for food, housing, and car payments, and those predetermined amounts will not be considered when establishing the amounts filers must pay to their creditors to resolve debts.

Ransom filed for consumer bankruptcy in order to resolve approximately $80,000 of unsecured debt. After filing his bankruptcy petition, Ransom sought to take advantage of the $471 monthly deduction for car payments. However, one of the credit card companies to which Ransom owed a debt objected, claiming that he was not entitled to the deduction because his vehicle was fully paid off.

Ransom filed a lawsuit, seeking to keep the car payment deduction. Lower courts ruled against him, and Justice Kagan upheld those rulings. “In short, Ransom may not deduct loan or lease expenses when he does not have any,” she said, adding that such a deduction would allow Ransom to shield almost $30,000 from creditors over the life of the repayment plan, which would be improper in that “he does not in fact need for loan or lease payments,” she said.

Source: The Washington Post, “Kagan delivers her first judicial opinion, in bankruptcy case“, Robert Barnes, 12 January 2011

Posted on behalf of Gingold & Gingold

1718 Peachtree St NW, #385
Atlanta, GA 30309

Phone: (678) 915-2634

First Free

    Disclaimer Privacy Policy

    I have read the Disclaimer and Privacy Policy

    Our Client Reviews

    Gingold & Gingold LLC
    5.0 / 5.0

    Based on 28 reviews

    Jack L.

    They did an excellent job with my case. Jamie took the time to really listen and understand things. She delved into the details and was extremely knowledgeable and non judgmental. Very professional and they know what they are doing. Would definitely recommend!

    All C.

    Mr. Gingold was recommended by an attorney I had worked with previously. I met with Ira Gingold to discuss credit issues. He went over each specific issue thoroughly. He advised me of the potential outcomes. He did all this in one meeting for a very reasonable price. When we finished I was confident in moving forward with a resolution. He definitely wants to help people take the appropriate course of action for their circumstance.

    Karen B.

    Dear Mr Gingold, There are so many reasons to be thankful for all you have done and will do. Anyone who has ever had unfavorable experiences with an attorney or the legal system will feel the trepidation that I experienced once I realized that my situation seemed hopeless. It was by chance and happily good luck that I decided to put my future and sanity into your hands. I was mortified at having to deal with my debts by claiming bankruptcy. I remember in our first meeting how you assured me that I was not alone and should not feel ashamed. And, anyone in this position obviously does not have money to spare and you were clear about all the costs and allowing me to pay according to my own ability to do so. You advised me in all aspects of the law, but also, you were at each meeting incredibly supportive and complementary of my personal and professional plans. Anyone else in this situation should feel blessed to have access to your expertise and support.

    Lyla B.

    I thought the process of filing bankruptcy was going to be a difficult one. However, Gingold & Gingold treated me with respect and dignity from the moment I walked through their door. I had the pleasure of working with Jamie. She is very responsive, professional, and knowledgeable. She took the time and listened to my every concern and handled each and every one of them to my satisfaction. My experience with filing bankruptcy under Gingold & Gingold's representation exceeded my expectations in a major way. They gave me such a peace of mind. I am very pleased with my decision of going with Gingold & Gingold to represent me when I filed Chapter 13 bankruptcy.

    Julie T.

    Wow! I am finally out of debt and can say that I am debt free after completing my chapter 7 bankruptcy case with Gingold and Gingold. Mr dangled was very knowledgeable and direct with regard to my debt situation. there were no surprises and the case went as I was advised. The staff was also very helpful whenever I had a question. I will definitely recommend them in the future to my friends.

    Sherard W.

    I cannot say enough about this law firm. From the initial consultation to our discharge, the entire office kept me updated with every step of the entire process. I came to the Gingold after a bad experience with another law firm. Ira and Jamie immediately began treating me like family through this experience. In the end, they assisted with eliminating many debts including my 2nd mortgage. I cannot say enough about the experience and knowledge that Ira brought to the table from the office visits to the court time. Thank you very much for helping me through this tough time. Thank you.

    Write a review